Page 1 of 1

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 12:39 am
by Athol
Louis Bouyer the great modern Catholic theologian states: “…the Church of the Gentiles subsists only as a graft on the trunk of Israel…Christianity will always be the legacy of Israel, which the Jews alone could give to the whole of mankind…”. Louis Bouyer calls the Church of the Circumcision, Judeo-Christianity, and states that it “cannot be considered a transitory phase of abolished Christianity” replaced and superseded by Gentile Catholicism. He emphasizes that Judeo-Christianity is the mother form of the Faith and the one which all other forms of Catholicism must have recourse to for authentic renewal and development. He perceives that it is a great weakness for the Church that the Jewish form of Catholicism does not at present subsist fully in the Church but only in tracings. Louis Bouyer believes that the Church will not reach its ultimate stage of development until the Jewish form of Catholicism has been rediscovered and allowed to fully live and breathe in the Church. This Jewish Church must express the definitive expression of the Gospel in the forms and categories of Judaism contained in both the Written and oral Torah of Judaism for the sake of the whole Church. Louis Bouyer states: “The Word of the Gospel, as Christ uttered it, as the apostles elucidated it, is woven entirely of the written Word of the Old Testament and its living commentary in Jewish tradition. To uproot them from the New Testament would make it not only incomprehensible but dumb and empty, for all its notions, images and vocabulary, like all the realities to which this totality applies, proceeds from the Old Testament, and from the unwritten as well as the written Torah.” He sees the survival of Judaism outside the church as providential for Christians during this period until the time they enter the Church bringing the full Israelite heritage with them. He sees this as the final blossoming of ‘the great tree of all the sons of Abraham”.

Cheers athol

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 12:45 am
by Athol
Pope Benedict XVI states that the Catechism of the Catholic Church “holds principally to the portrayal of Jesus in the Gospel of Matthew, seeing in Jesus the Messiah, the greatest in the kingdom of Heaven: as such he knew he was “to fulfill the Law by keeping it in its all embracing detail…down to ‘the least of these commandments’ (CCC 578)” The Catechism thus connects the special mission of Jesus to his fidelity to the Law…” Cardinal Schonborn also speaks of this fidelity of Jesus to the Torah as his food as mention above. Jesus lived the Torah perfectly as did his Mother. In their persons they represent all Israel’s fidelity to the Torah. This perfect fidelity allows the Messiah through his life, death and resurrection to open the Torah to be universalized. Pope Benedict states: ‘The faith of Israel is directed to universality…But, the Law, in which it was expressed, was particular, quite concretely directed to Israel and its history; it could not be universalized in this form. In the intersection of these paradoxes stands Jesus of Nazareth, who himself as a Jew lived under the Law of Israel but knew himself to be at the same time the mediator of the universality of God…Jesus opened up the Law…claiming to be, acting as Son, with the authority of God himself…Jesus broadened the Law, wanted to open it up…but in strictest obedience to its fulfillment…”. The Pope sees that in God the Law and the Promise are One in person of the Messiah. He also sees that one cannot just separate out the moral laws of the Torah and leave the rest. The Torah is a whole and the Revelation of God. He says “…one cannot simply separate out universally valid moral principles and transitory ritual and legal norms without destroying the Torah itself, which is something integral, which owes its existence to God’s address to Israel. The idea that, on the one hand, there are pure morals which are reasonable and universal, and on the other that there are rites that are conditioned by time and ultimately dispensable mistakes entirely the inner structure of the five books of Moses. The ‘Decalogue’ as the core of the work of the Law shows clearly enough that the worship of God is completely indivisible from morals, cult, and ethos.”

Great Quotes...

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 4:08 am
by Hadassah
Wonderful quotes from Cardinal Ratzinger, and a great place to go with this discussion.

It would seem useful to put these quotes together with what precedes and what follows them. If anyone is reading along, Athol is quoting from _Many Religious, One Covenant_ by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger.

Cardinal Ratzinger begins by noting that the Catechism states that: (1) "the Law is led to its fullness through the renewal of the heart” (CCC 1968) and (2) “externally this results in a suspension of ritual and juridical observances” (CCC 1972).

He continues: “How could this happen? How is this compatible with fulfillment of the Law to the last iota?” He goes on to explain how this can be.

Next follow the statements that you accurately just quoted. But you say that he implies that “perfect fidelity" allows the Messiah through his life, death and resurrection to open the Torah to be universalized.”

I don’t think that Cardinal Ratzinger says that perfect fidelity allows the Messiah to open the Torah to be universalized. He does say:

“Jesus opened up the Law quite theologically conscious of, and claiming to be, acting as Son, with the authority of God himself, and innermost unity with God the Father. Only God himself could fundamentally reinterpret the Law and manifest that it’s broadening transformation and conservation is its actually intended meaning. Jesus’ interpretation of the Law makes sense only if it is interpretation with divine authority.”

He notes that this must end in a conflict for Jews:

“Only when one penetrates to this point can he also see the tragic depth of the conflict.”

“On the one hand, Jesus broadened the Law, wanted to open it up, not as a liberal reformer, not out of lesser loyalty to the Law, but in strictest obedience to its fulfillment, out of his being one with the Father in whom alone Law and promise are one and in whom Israel could become blessing and salvation for the nations.”

“On the other hand, Israel ‘had to’ see here something much more serious than a violation of this or that commandment (my insertion: implying that at a basic level Israel would have seen Jesus’ reinterpretation as a violation), namely the injuring of that basic disobedience, of the actual core of its revelation and faith: Hear, O Israel, your God is one God. Here obedience (my insertion: to Jesus’ divine reinterpretation of the Law) clashes with obedience (my insertion: to the one true God).

This conflict, says Cardinal Ratzinger, can only be resolved on the cross!

A few paragraphs later, he later notes the following: “The New Testament sees the death of Christ in this perspective, as a fulfillment of this course of events. This meant that all cultic ordinances of the Old Testament are seen to be taken up into his death and brought to their deepest meaning. All sacrifices are acts of representation, which, from symbols, in the great act of real representation become reality, so that the symbols can be dropped without one iota being lost.”

Galatians...

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 4:11 am
by Hadassah
My Dear Athol,

Interestingly, while reading Sacred Scripture earlier this afternoon, Galatians 2:11ff came to my attention. I was drawn back to your point that all the early Jews observed the law zealously. This, of course, is that passage that harkens back to Paul’s advisory role in the Council of Jerusalem.

“And when Kephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face because he clearly was wrong. For, until some people came from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles; but when they came, he began to draw back and separated himself, because he was afraid of the circumcised. And the rest of the Jews (also) acted hypocritically along with him, with the result that even Barnabas was carried away by their hypocrisy. But when I saw that they were not on the right road in line with the truth of the gospel, I said to Kephas in front of all, "If you, though a Jew, are living like a Gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?"

Blessings,
Hadassah

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 4:30 am
by Hadassah
Please understand that I uphold the privileged place of Israel in the plan of God and treasure the foundation on which Christianity is built and the origins from which the Church continues to draw. I am, however, interested in honestly understanding and reflecting on Scripture and the teaching of the Church as it relates to this topic. I find it necessary in these situations to proceed with great care in interpretation.

Blessings,
Hadassah

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 7:02 pm
by Ariel
Athol and Hadassah,

I am glad to see you're having quite a lively debate on this issue.

For future reference, please try to avoid very long citations on the forum if possible - it would be better to add a link if the text is already online elsewhere.

Regarding your quote from Gal 2, Hadassah, I would be careful to not read into the text what is not there. Paul is not upset at Peter because Peter is keeping Torah. The passage says that the problem was that Peter was causing a situation of division between Jewish and Gentile believers, and also apparently because he may have been "compelling the Gentiles to live like Jews."

Ariel

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 8:44 pm
by Hadassah
Regarding your quote from Gal 2, Hadassah, I would be careful to not read into the text what is not there. Paul is not upset at Peter because Peter is keeping Torah.
How is it, then, that Peter is (in Paul's words) "not living like a Jew"?

I apologize for the quotes, but I did not see another way to do that that was clear. And I do not know a site where that book is published.

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:38 pm
by Athol
Dear Hadassah,

When the Pope is talking about cultic observances he is referring to the priesthood and sacrifices of the Temple. In Messiah these have been fulfilled and transformed into the new priesthood and the New Sacrifice. The inner principles of the system are still valid but the outward forms are transformed to reflect the reality that the Messiah has come as High Priest and victim. This of course is done through the power of the Cross.

Also Galatians is written by St Paul to Gentiles not Jews and much be read in that light. the same goes for Corinthians and other letters.

As for the situation between Peter and Paul it was nothing to do with eating kosher but a question of following the extreme rules instituted by the Shammai school of Pharisees which made it almost impossible for Gentiles to eat with Jews. At this time the school of Hillel with its more loving approach was not dominant but the school of shammai was and they instituted a number of new rulings to which the Hillelites were opposed that enforce greater separation between jews and Gentiles. It wasn't until the destruction of the Temple etc that it was decided by a voice from heaven that the rulings of the school of Hillel would be followed when they clashed with those of the school of Shammai.
To think that Peter was sitting down and eating a pork chop with oysters with the Gentiles is ridiculous. Both Peter and Paul and all the early Jewish Church were observant of the teaching of the Torah. I also think that it may have taken time for the early Jewish Church to understand that the new Gentile Christians were not in the same category as Gentile idolaters. It is obvious Peter was having struggles in this area and when a group of believers who came from Shammaite background were present he separated himself from eating at the same table with them.

Cheers athol

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:47 pm
by Athol
Reconciling Torah and Gospel- Pope Benedict XVI

http://www.ewtn.com/library/CATECHSM/GOSTORAH.HTM

Posted: Sun Aug 24, 2008 9:53 pm
by Hadassah
Heavy sigh :-)...

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 7:05 am
by Athol
Dear Hadassah,

I have been thinking what it would mean if your interpretation or those similiar to it is correct and the final word on this topic.

From what I understand of your position (which is similiar to the position of many others) - a Jew who becomes a Catholic can if he wants keep some of the customs of his heritage as his/her personal spiritual discipline but this is just one's own quaint or eccentric choice and doesn't really have any meaning for the Church or God's plan of salvation. There is no collective mission or vocation just a need by those who are still clinging to the burdensome old rules of Judaism and the torah while those Jews who become Catholics who jettison their entire vocation as an Israelite and their heritage as Jews embrace and enter the wonderful world of Gentile 'law-free' Christianity. Judasim is an old dead relic which is only useful as a museum to show how Catholicism developed. There is now no special calling and mission for the Jewish people other than to embrace Gentile assimilation in the Church and bring about the end of the Jewish people.

If this is true then the fears of the Rabbis about 'conversion' to Christianity and Catholicism are totally valid and a form of genocide by assimilation. Nothing has changed still the old model of total assimilation but letting those Jews who feel a nostalgia for the past to cling to a few old Jewish trappings rather than putting them before the Spanish Inquisition. Also letting them have a bit of a jewish dress up will be good for proselytising other Jews and 'converting' them as long as they don't really see any significance in their old Jewish observances. Let them eat bagels and lox and dance some lovely old Jewish dances- we don't mind a few nice ethnic touches but as for a unique vocation and a continuing mission for Jews and Judaism in God's plan of salvation that is all heresy and Jewish bunk.

Cheers Athol

O God, Let All The Nations, Praise You!

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 11:05 am
by Hadassah
Wow! That's a lot of interpretation to impose on an argument that I've for the most part only kept in Scripture and Catechism...
...but this is just one's own quaint or eccentric choice...Also letting them have a bit of aJjewish dress up will be good for proselytising other Jews and 'converting' them as long as they don't really see any significance in their old Jewish observances. Let them eat bagels and lox and dance some lovely old Jewish dances- we don't mind a few nice ethnic touches
I have to say that the above are examples (among other statements in your scenario) of what would constitute a truly condescending attitude ~ one that I hope I have not manifested in this conversation, despite the fact that I disagree with you that Jews are still bound to Torah observance. This would be like "patting you on the head" and I would not treat you this way.
as for a unique vocation and a continuing mission for Jews and Judaism in God's plan of salvation that is all heresy and Jewish bunk.
And this cannot stand for several reasons, not least of which is that it is not the understanding or teaching of the Church!
...rather than putting them before the Spanish Inquisition...
And I’m not even going to talk about what I think about even mentioning this kind of thing!

I don’t agree that all of that is the natural conclusion of my argument here. I don’t pretend to have an authoritative interpretation of what it means in today’s world for the Jews to be set apart, and to fulfill their mission and vocation before the Lord. This is something that I am in the process of pondering, and it would be my hope that someone like you would help me to do that.

I do think that it’s possible (and I don’t think I’m alone in this among those who think seriously and with a spirit of charity on this) that some of those things that served as signs of the covenant have been transformed. If I understand your view, only their meaning has been changed. I think that Scripture might indicate that so have the signs themselves. One thing I do know is this: Even if the Lord has transformed the signs, He is still capable of ensuring that there is no “end to the Jewish people.”

I do become frustrated (thus my heavy sigh) with responses such as the one to Galatians 2 regarding the Hillelites and the Shammaites. Paul says very directly, "If you, though a Jew, are living like a Gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?" You seem to suggest that what he really means is something like, “If you, though a more loving Jew, are living like a more harsh and intolerant Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?” That doesn’t seem to fit and it takes the long way around to explain what seems to me a very clear text. And it certainly doesn’t fit ~ in my opinion; I am sure that have a different take on it :-) ~ with Acts 10:13ff.

Please remember, Athol, that we are one in Christ...

With love, in Christ...
Hadassah

Clarification...

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 12:34 pm
by Hadassah
despite the fact that I disagree with you that Jews are still bound to Torah observance
I should say that I disagree that Jews who have accepted Christ are still bound to some points of Torah observance.

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 12:54 pm
by Athol
Dear Hadassah,

i am sure you are a great person and really are trying to understand these issues in sincerity. Maybe I have put what I see as the logical outcome of such thinking a bit bluntly- but think about it -it is what you are saying if one holds to your understanding. Yes it is important to discuss these things from the scriptural and church teaching aspects. I also do not think it is simple to understand anything written by Paul or Peter if one doesn't see them in their Jewish context. I would like to ask you a question; What are the Jews without Torah and mitzvot?

Cheers Athol

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 1:11 pm
by Athol
Just to clarify. I do not think that Jews who have accepted Christ are bound to some Torah observances i believe they are bound to the Torah (as are the Gentile Believers) and observance of the mitzvot will differ depending on ones calling and vocation in the Body and ones level of understanding. Torah and Grace are not opposed to one another they work together and serve together.

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 1:26 pm
by Ariel
hi Hadassah,

Just out of curiosity, are you Jewish?
Hadassah wrote:Please understand that I uphold the privileged place of Israel in the plan of God and treasure the foundation on which Christianity is built and the origins from which the Church continues to draw.
How would you propose, then, for this "privileged place of Israel in the plan of God" to be expressed if the conversion of the Jews would practically effect to their assimilation with no binding, practical obligation to their special covenant with God (except for maybe a bit of cosmetic folklore that they might retain?)

PS: no worries about the quotes, my comment was mostly directed at Athol who outdid you by far with lengthy quotes. :wink:

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 1:38 pm
by Ariel
Hadassah wrote: How is it, then, that Peter is (in Paul's words) "not living like a Jew"?
I'm not sure what exactly Paul meant, but as Athol says I very much doubt that it means that Peter was sitting down having some pork chops with the gentiles.

Keep in mind the decision of the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15):

"19 Therefore I judge that we should not trouble those from among the Gentiles who are turning to God, 20 but that we write to them to abstain from things polluted by idols, from sexual immorality,from things strangled, and from blood. 21 For Moses has had throughout many generations those who preach him in every city, being read in the synagogues every Sabbath."

What is James saying here? When he says that Gentiles should not be burdened with commandments that were never intended for them in the first place, is he not assuming a distinction between them and the Jewish believers? James' concessions are explicitly given to the gentiles - and the underlying assumption is that these concessions are not granted for Jewish believers - otherwise James could have just plainly said that the Torah was not binding on anyone anymore! On the contrary, he even affirms that Moses is still "read in the synagogues every Sabbath" - and what is the value of reading without doing?

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 3:04 pm
by Hadassah
Yes, I do acknowlede that the verdict of the Council is only for the Gentiles and so that's something we have to think about. However, if we are true to the text, we also have to ackowledge that the message that Peter hears is in very personal terms!

(Acts 10:13ff) A voice said to him, "Get up, Peter. Slaughter and eat." But Peter said, "Certainly not, sir. For never have I eaten anything profane and unclean." The voice spoke to him again, a second time, "What God has made clean, you are not to call profane."

Peter, you slaughter and you eat. He even objects on the grounds that he has never violated dietary laws! And the response comes back... Three times...

I think it's worth at least thinking about why God put this message in such personal terms for Peter, a Jew who is Torah-observant. Why not something along the lines of, "Peter, let these Gentiles eat as they want to. It's not a problem for them." That's not the way it reads and I don't think we can ignore that.

Peter's Dream

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 4:34 pm
by Richard
Hi Hadassah,

I don't think you can learn much about the observance of the commandments Jesus requires of the Jew from Peter's dream.
Peter never communicates this message to the other apostles, and, in all likelihood, for a very good reason: he himself, does not interpret it as permitting forbidden foods, but rather, as permitting a forbidden contact between people: [28] and he said to them, "You yourselves know how unlawful it is for a Jew to associate with or to visit any one of another nation; but God has shown me that I should not call any man common or unclean."
In any case, the vision is ambiguous. If Jesus had meant to teach him that forbidden foods are permitted, the vision should have presented him with only those animals which are forbidden to eat. Since they included all kinds of animals, they gave him the option of killing and eating the kosher animals among them.

It is unthinkable that Biblical prohibitions that stand at the very center of Jewish religious life would be abrogated by an ambiguous message communicated in a waking dream. And if Peter had presented his dream as a message from Jesus suspending the laws of kashrut to the Jerusalem community they would have rejected it for good reason, indeed, for the same reason that the Church rejects revelations to individuals: it contradicted the word of G-d in the Bible. The issue of eating forbidden meats was to remain a real one for Christians for a long time. There is even a passage in the Didache which encourages abstinence from unkosher meats: “But concerning meat, bear that which thou art able to do. But keep with care from things sacrificed to idols, for it is the worship of the infernal deities.” [Didache 6:3, ca. 50-120

All the best,
Richard

Re: Peter's Dream

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2008 5:08 pm
by Hadassah
Only have time for some quick commentary right now....

Can't learn much from it? It's Sacred Scripture. This has to be held in tension with all the rest of it. I'm saying that it has to be considered.
Peter never communicates this message to the other apostles
He does, in fact, communicate it word for word in chapter 11.
he himself, does not interpret it as permitting forbidden foods, but rather, as permitting a forbidden contact between people: [28] and he said to them, "You yourselves know how unlawful it is for a Jew to associate with or to visit any one of another nation; but God has shown me that I should not call any man common or unclean."
I think you are correct that it is a two-fold message. But he clearly does interpret it as relating it to food at some point, because eventually, it leads to the verdict of the Council which is related to food (albeit for the Gentiles).
Since they included all kinds of animals, they gave him the option of killing and eating the kosher animals among them.
Then Peter should have had no objection to the "Slaughter and eat." command. Why does he react saying, but nothing unclean heas ever touched my lips? He should have just shrugged it off.
And if Peter had presented his dream as a message from Jesus suspending the laws of kashrut to the Jerusalem community they would have rejected it for good reason, indeed, for the same reason that the Church rejects revelations to individuals: it contradicted the word of G-d in the Bible.
I started on this, but will have to come back to it later. If you are Catholic, I would say this. Peter is not a random individual. Just recall, that Christ has given him the keys and the power to bind and loose in these words (Mt. 16:19): "I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."

Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 1:13 pm
by Athol
Dear Hadassah and all,

Just to let you know I probably won't be around for a couple of weeks as I am going to Ireland early Thursday morning and won't be using the internet until I get to the US.

Cheers Athol

Welcome...

Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 1:55 pm
by Hadassah
Welcome, in advance to the U.S.!!! Your travel will give me some time :-). Busy weeks ahead. Safe travels.

Article by Ian H. Henderson

Posted: Wed Aug 27, 2008 6:43 am
by Ariel
Richard just emailed me a link to an interesting article on legalism and anti-nomianism called Law and Unlaw by Ian H. Henderson which I though was relevant to the discussion here.

Early Church Instruction

Posted: Wed Aug 27, 2008 12:56 pm
by Hadassah
Thanks Richard and Ariel.

Does anyone know whether any of the documents of the very early Church (perhaps the Didache or a similar item) talk about a difference in how to instruct Jewish vs. Gentile/pagan converts to Christianity regarding Torah observance? For example, "ensure that Jewish converts know that they are still bound to observances as they have been laid out for the Jewish people, but remind Gentiles that they are not bound by certain aspects (e.g. circumcision, dietary laws, etc). I can do the research at some point, but I thought if anyone knows of something...

Monica and Augustine, pray for us...

Re: Peter's Dream

Posted: Wed Aug 27, 2008 1:13 pm
by Hadassah
The issue of eating forbidden meats was to remain a real one for Christians for a long time. There is even a passage in the Didache which encourages abstinence from unkosher meats: “But concerning meat, bear that which thou art able to do. But keep with care from things sacrificed to idols, for it is the worship of the infernal deities.” [Didache 6:3, ca. 50-120]
Strictly speaking, in the context of the Didiache, is not food sacrificed to idols a different thing from what is unkosher?

Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2008 11:42 am
by Ariel
hi Hadassah,

re. your question about early church documents attesting differences in Jewish/Gentile believers and Torah observance - Justin Martyr talks about it somewhat in his dialogue with Trypho. His opinion regarding Torah observance is tolerant but not exactly positive.

The truth is that all Church Fathers were Gentiles, and almost none of them could really appreciate the richness of Torah from experience. They all judged it "from the outside," so to say, as a legalistic burden rather than a joyful consecration to God in every aspect of life.

I personally consider that the growing greater appreciation of Torah is a recent development of doctrine: the seed is there in the NT but it was never really developed in the history of the Church.

Why the common negative view of the Torah? Because Paul devoted much of his energy to drive home two points:

1) Gentiles are not obligated to submit to the Torah
2) Jews are not SAVED by the Torah

Paul's strong rhetoric in addressing the two above points sometimes gives the impression that he intends to discard the Torah as obsolete. But this cannot be true in the light of several NT passages (Mt 5:17-20, Acts 16:1-3; Acts 21:17-26; Rom 3:1-2; 7:12, 16; 9:4-5; 1 Ti 1:8).

Ariel

Holy Spirit and Church

Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 11:58 am
by Hadassah
Ariel wrote:...the seed is there in the NT but it was never really developed in the history of the Church.
Respectfully and honestly... Why do you think that the Holy Spirit would allow this? It is baffling to me that the Church, guided in all truth by the Holy Spirit, regardless of the personal prejudices which might have been present in individuals, has completely missed for so long a time a critical requirement (if you are correct) for Jews who embrace Catholicism. Such an integral part of the covenant for the Jews and the Holy Spirit allows the Church for more of her history than not to simply ignore it? Why would the Holy Spirit allow that to happen?

Posted: Mon Sep 08, 2008 3:46 pm
by Athol
The Holy Spirit blows where he wills. There is a time for every season- the last 2000 years have been the special time of mercy for the Gentiles- this is drawing to a close- and so a new stage in salvation history is beginning which will see the ingrafting of the Jews as prophecied by Paul.

Cheers from the Ring of Kerry

Posted: Sun Mar 22, 2009 8:12 am
by Gerat Tzedek
Gerat Tzedek wrote:
Ariel wrote:Yes, I would generally tend to agree with Athol, though I might formulate it a bit differently. I do believe that one of the main reasons for the 'failure' of the Church to bring Christ to the Jewish people was that this would have caused their assimilation and practical dissolution of their Jewish identity.
The argument that Jews have avoided conversion because conversion meant leaving their community and full assimilation into another seems reasonable. However, it is not true, and I will give you two proofs why it is not the case.

The first proof is the massive assimilation of Jews into the secular world. So Jews are obviously not immune to giving up their beliefs or assimilating. It's specifically YOUR religion that is unattractive to us.

The second proof is that Protestant Christianity came to this same conclusion decades ago and has already marketed Messianic Judaism as a result. The results are in and are not at all what Protestants hoped. The number of Jewish converts to Christianity is as dismal as ever. On the other hand, the Messianic movement has attracted GENTILES like flies. The movement is literally bursting at the seems with gentiles -- it should change its name to Messianic Gentilism. The problem is that many of these gentiles have a true afinity for Judaism, but soon find what many Jews notice -- that Messianic Judaism really is NOT a Judaism. They leave and many of them end up having valid halachic conversions to Judaism.

My guess is that if you truly get your Hebrew-Catholic movement going, you will similarly find gentile Catholics expressing interest, and then leaving for Judaism. And indeed when I was in the Yahoo group for Hebrew Catholics, before my conversion to Judaism, the overwhelming number of people there were NOT NOT NOT halachically Jewish, but were gentiles.

Posted: Sun Mar 22, 2009 3:14 pm
by Athol
Dear Tzedek,

Some of what you say is true especially with certain types of Messianic Jews. However some groups that were more "Jewish" liturgically and in practice had more Jews and less Gentiles in their Messianic synagogue in my experience. As for the Hebrew Catholics in the yahoo group they are the ones that are more comfortable with discussing their Jewish and Catholic identity on the internet (which of course interests many people non- Jewish Catholics)- many other Jews in the Catholic church are more hidden and secretive as they may have hurts from the past or not wanting family and others to learn of their identity. Of course there are many thousands of Catholics who are halakically Jewish according to Orthodox Judaism but these people have ceased to identify as Jewish as they have been Catholic for 3 or 4 generations. Some of them are becoming interested in their Jewish heritage. For me it is the spirituality of being a Jewish Catholic that most appeals to me- I would not feel fulfilled with just a Gentile Catholic spirituality and identity nor a purely Orthodox Jewish one (though Breslov is the most appealing to me). I love Rebbe Nachman and I love St John of the Cross. Each person must choose their own spiritual path and journey and I respect that but feel there is a real gap for those such as myself and our aim is to create our own community for those drawn to this way not in order to actively missionise Jews especially by pushy agressive means, which seems to be the purpose of many of these Messianic groups. The personal encounter and relationship with the eucharistic Jesus and his mother is worth all the struggle and misunderstanding from both Catholics and Jews. I also have a love for Torah and mitzvot which in fact enables me to love the Torah observant Mary, Jesus and Joseph even more. Others see it differently and I certainly respect their search to live out the truth as they believe it to be. I hope they pray for me as I pray for them in our unique journeys to the Ultimate Truth.

Posted: Sun Mar 22, 2009 10:46 pm
by Ariel
It's specifically YOUR religion that is unattractive to us.
Out of curiosity Gerat Tsedek, what is the main point that you are trying to make here? I may be wrong, but I have the impression that you have a bone to pick, with some amount of frustration in the tone of your posts.

You state that you converted to Judaism. Perhaps you could tell us more about that conversion. I'm just wondering what you hope to receive and/or contribute on our forum. You are more than welcome to continue with the discussions of course, I'm just wondering where you're coming from...

Ariel

Posted: Mon Mar 23, 2009 11:38 pm
by Gerat Tzedek
I first met Orthodox Jews when I was thirty, and subsequently began studying Judaism in depth. It began a 15 year long push-me pull-you that was very difficult for me. After all, one does not really need to become a Jew, and I couldn't articulate what it was that kept bringing me back, even though I was basically making the effort to be happy away from it. But I knew from that time that if I ever found out that I had Jewish ancestry, I would immediately become observant and do what it took to clear up issues of status.

That became fact. I found out my maternal great-great grandmother was a Jew. It was nothing that would stand up before a Beis Din -- I was not halachically Jewish. But it was way more than enough to tip the scales. So I went through Orthodox conversion.

I came into this forum because I do believe Israel is in danger. I believe we are headed for another holocaust -- anti-Semitism is on the rise worldwide, we have a madman at the helm in Iran, and the charter of Hamas calls for the killing of all Jews EVERYWHERE. WE need allies, and we need them NOW. Not after the shower doors have shut.

And yes, you do sense frustration. The whole "Hebrew-Catholic" thing drove me absolutely nuts before my conversion. Probably more than any other single factor. I saw a few genuinely sincere Jews seeking to live their covenant. But mostly I saw a lot of goyim with distant distant connections to Jews who lived hundreds of years ago who didn't know what the heck they were talking about, spewing ignorance, disrespecting Israel, who really had no intention of identifying as Jews or living a covenantal life. They were just into sentimental pseudo-Jewish nonsense and sometimes I got so angry I just didn't know what to do with myself. There is nothing more insulting to Israel than wannabe-Jews who feel perfectly free to fool around with what is sacred to us.

The second thing that is a frustration, both then and now, is that despite there being exceptions to the rule here in this forum, THE RULE STILL EXISTS that Jews baptised into the church are lost to Israel. They become indistingishable from any other gentile Catholic. They lose touch with the Jewish community. They are basically stolen. It's wrong. I'm not going to tell you HOW to fix it. There are a number of different ways, some more to my liking, some more to your liking. My ideas...I'll keep to myself, as I am a guest here. But I think that you Catholics can look the problem sqarely in the face, and try to solve it: How can you, as Catholics, ASSIST the Jews in your midst to remain faithful to Covenant, rather than enable them to break Covenant as has been the norm?

The third frustration is basically this: most of the ignorance of Catholics about Jews is not the simple ignorance that can be corrected with education. Rather, it is the arrogant ignorance that DOESN'T WANT to be taught. The problem is sytemic. I remember a priest who taught in his homily that Jews don't understand that G-d is our Father. This was not an ignorant parishioner, but one of your finest, eductated in your seminaries. Individual Catholics here and there may care, but the Church as a whole? The Church does not care about enough about Jews to try to understand them. It regulates the topic to a committee and forgets about them. And THAT is not only frustrating, but very demoralizing and bitter for a person who once hoped for progress between Catholics and Jews.

Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2009 2:47 am
by Hadassah
Hello Gerat Tzedek:
Gerat Tzedek wrote:The second thing that is a frustration, both then and now, is that despite there being exceptions to the rule here in this forum, THE RULE STILL EXISTS that Jews baptised into the church are lost to Israel. They become indistingishable from any other gentile Catholic. They lose touch with the Jewish community. They are basically stolen. It's wrong. I'm not going to tell you HOW to fix it.
Just wanting to clarify what you are saying here... Are you telling us that if a Jew were baptized, accepting Jesus Christ as the divine Son of G-d and embracing the idea of a New Convenant AND he remained observant, he would not be lost to Israel and there would be no cause for strain on his relationship with his observant Jewish community?

Many Blessings,
Hadassah

Posted: Tue Mar 24, 2009 12:09 pm
by Ariel
Gerat Tsedek,

wow this is quite the journey. Thanks for sharing your point of view so clearly. I can totally empathize with your frustrations.

You are right that Israel needs allies, and its about time that Catholics wake up to that fact, and realize that it is a biblical imperative to stand up with the people of the Covenant.

I understand your frustration with the Hebrew-Catholic movement. You are not alone in this. There are actually a number of Catholic Jews who are distressed that the whole movement really seems to retain only an outer varnish of Jewish practices. As you can see from our website, we definitely support the development and establishment of a genuine Jewish-Catholic spirituality.
THE RULE STILL EXISTS that Jews baptized into the church are lost to Israel. They become indistingishable from any other gentile Catholic. They lose touch with the Jewish community. They are basically stolen.
I think the biggest problem here is that most baptized Jews come from a secular background with little to no understanding of orthodox Judaism. So it's not exactly that entering the Church makes them lose their Judaism, perhaps it's more like they never knew it in the first place.
How can you, as Catholics, ASSIST the Jews in your midst to remain faithful to Covenant, rather than enable them to break Covenant as has been the norm?
Right now it's hard to say because there is no serious Jewish-Catholic spirituality in place in the Church. My suggestion at this point would be: If a Jew is baptized and becomes Catholic, he/she should also study Judaism and join a living Jewish community, pray in the Synagogue, celebrate the feasts, and live according to the halakhah. I am aware that this will not be easy, and that he/she may face rejection as much on the Jewish as on the Catholic side. But I don't see any other solution right now. To bridge a 2,000 year gap between Church and Synagogue will not happen in a day. In addition, it seems to me that this is the way it went in the early Church: Jewish-Christians continued to attend the Temple and synagogue in communion with Israel, while also attending the home churches of the first (Jewish) Christians.
There are a number of different ways, some more to my liking, some more to your liking. My ideas...I'll keep to myself, as I am a guest here.
Actually I would be interested in your ideas if you wouldn't mind sharing them with us.
most of the ignorance of Catholics about Jews is not the simple ignorance that can be corrected with education. Rather, it is the arrogant ignorance that DOESN'T WANT to be taught.
I'm not sure this applies to MOST serious Catholics, but yes with this I think you are right too. When the ignorance is willful and stubborn, I think the main thing we can do is to pray for such people, because such attitudes reveal above all a need for conversion before there can be true change, unfortunately.

Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2009 12:12 am
by Gerat Tzedek
Hadassah wrote: Just wanting to clarify what you are saying here... Are you telling us that if a Jew were baptized, accepting Jesus Christ as the divine Son of G-d and embracing the idea of a New Convenant AND he remained observant, he would not be lost to Israel and there would be no cause for strain on his relationship with his observant Jewish community?

Many Blessings,
Hadassah
I'm not sure that such a thing is possible, even if it is attempted.

I suspect that some of the commandments, such as kashrut, were put into place for the purpose of seperating Israel from the nations. I just really don't say how a Jew can keep completely kosher and be in close community with gentiles. Aquaintences, yes. Friends, no. Why? Because when you stop to think about it, community is constantly sharing food, and in the end what kashrut comes down to is that Jews cannot share food with gentiles.

Being observant is HARD. We manage because we support each other as a community. There is a reason why Jewish men gather in a minyan to pray at least once a day. A reason we gather on Shabbat and feast days. For a Jew to be outside of Jewish community, to be alone and within Catholic community, they do not have this support, they do not have their Jewish family to help hold them up.

However, instructing them that this is their birthright and responsibility is really the only right thing for you to do. I really don't see how you can get around it. The only question is how BEST for them to keep their covenant?

Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2009 11:30 am
by Hadassah
Hello,
Gerat Tzedek wrote:"However, instructing them that this is their birthright and responsibility is really the only right thing for you to do. I really don't see how you can get around it. The only question is how BEST for them to keep their covenant?
The question of how baptized observant Jews could best keep covenant obligations outside of an observant Jewish community is an interesting one to think about, of course. How would observant baptized Jews know how to proceed, those who require halachic consultation? In your vision, who would decide or legislate such issues? Is it left to the individual?

Many Blessings,
Hadassah

Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2009 11:40 am
by Ariel
I don't think that would be possible Hadassah. Judaism is by its nature very communitarian, and keeping halakhah is centered around the community.

Posted: Wed Mar 25, 2009 12:58 pm
by Hadassah
Hi Ariel,

Yes, I understand. But Gerat Tzedak put forth the vision that the Church should encourage (observant) baptized Jews in the keeping the law in the best way possible, given that they would be outside the community already. I'd like to hear more about what she might envision for the Church in terms of positive action. How might that all work? What might be acceptable?

Many Blessings,
Hadassah

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2009 2:47 pm
by mikemac
Hi. I find this thread fascinating.

After catching up by reading all the posts I went to the Association of Hebrew Catholics web site. They link to your web site Ariel.

From their web site under Studies I went to "Themes of Salvation History" and listened to Lecture number 8 from Nov. 7, 2007 by Dr. Lawrence Feingold titled "The Law of Moses and Its Fulfillment in Christ". Here's the link,
http://www.hebrewcatholic.org/Studies/M ... vatio.html

This is what I learned from this Lecture.

Dr. Lawrence Feingold asks the question if the Judicial Law (part of the Mosaic Law) should be binding for all time. He refers to the sermon on the mount and Acts 10 and Acts 15. Jesus tells His apostles to go and teach all nations but Dr. Feingold asks how could they do that with parts of the Law of Moses. He says in the Gospel of Mark, Mark tells us that Jesus already abrogated this part of the Law. He says the Natural Law of God (the 10 commandments) are binding for all time but about the Judicial Law (part of the Mosaic Law) it depends on circumstances so it is fitting that they change as circumstance change. He relates it to a 3 year old having different orders to follow from their parents than a 16 year old would. He also relates to the part of the Mosaic Law that says "Whoever strikes their mother or father will be put to death", the death penalty being abolished in a lot of jurisdictions. He says the Ceremonial Law of the Old Testament commemorates the Exodus and points to the salvation of Christ on the cross so it had to change after Jesus' death and resurrection. So he says the Ceremonial Law should change. In Christ's Passion we find the perfect accomplishment of the Law. Jesus also fulfills the Law in us with the Grace of the seven Sacraments. Jesus is the true Holocaust, the sacrificial first born. He finishes by saying we should be thankful that we received the 10 Commandments as well as the Grace of the Holy Spirit through the Sacraments to put it into practice. This is all taken from Dr. Feingold's lecture so please don't ban me for posting it.

This should not mean giving up your Jewish identity. I am not asked to give up my Canadian identity or my Highland Scot heritage by being a Catholic. The 144 thousand that administer to God when the new Jerusalem comes down from Heaven are from the twelve tribes, hence God keeps His promise for the land (Revelation Chapters 3, 7 & 21).

By the way I don't believe it is part of Catholic dogma (I may be wrong) but I do realize that in Malichi Chapter 4 it states "5 Behold I will send you Elias (Elijah) the prophet, before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord. 6 And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers: lest I come, and strike the earth with anathema." In the Epistle of Paul to the Romans, Chapters 9, 10 and 11 while Paul is lamenting for his brethren the spirit of Elias is also mentioned. And in Revelation Chapter 11 we see what will happen when the two witnesses, Henoch and Elias come to the holy city Jerusalem to prophesy clothed in sackcloth for 42 months.

God bless
Mike

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2009 3:26 pm
by Ariel
hi Mike,

If I would ban anyone with an opinion contrary to mine here I would probably end up alone in the forum :lol: Just kidding.

Dr. Feingold's opinion is pretty much the standard one of traditional Catholic theology. In my opinion it sounds convincing mostly because that it is familiar and we are not used to thinking outside this box. But where do the Scriptures ever make a distinction between the natural law/10 commandments and the judicial law? The fact is they don't. That is a scholastic, Thomistic distinction (unless I'm mistaken) that is understandable given its original context, but I'm not sure this artificial split of the Torah is really rooted in divine revelation, especially for Jews who feel that Torah observance is a real means of communion with God and not only a signpost that pointed to Christ that can now be discarded.

Ariel

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2009 3:39 pm
by mikemac
But Malachi does state Elias shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers. I guess maybe not quite yet. 2 Thessalonians Chapter 2 has to happen first before the 42 months start. :D

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2009 6:21 am
by Athol
Ariel wrote: Dr. Feingold's opinion is pretty much the standard one of traditional Catholic theology. In my opinion it sounds convincing mostly because that it is familiar and we are not used to thinking outside this box. But where do the Scriptures ever make a distinction between the natural law/10 commandments and the judicial law? The fact is they don't. That is a scholastic, Thomistic distinction (unless I'm mistaken) that is understandable given its original context, but I'm not sure this artificial split of the Torah is really rooted in divine revelation, especially for Jews who feel that Torah observance is a real means of communion with God and not only a signpost that pointed to Christ that can now be discarded.

Ariel
Yes Dr Feingold is a thomistic theologian and is a wonderful man and teacher but I disagree with him on a number of points and on this point Cardinal Lustiger and the Pope (writing as Cardinal Ratzinger) also seems to disagree. See Cardinal Lustiger's Book "The Promise" and Cardinal Ratzinger's comments on "Torah and the Gospel". St thomas has since proved to be wrong on a few issues such as the Immaculate Conception eventhough his philosophical approach to theology is an important treasure of the church but it is not the only way of approaching the truths of Scripture and the Faith.

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2009 9:21 pm
by Glory71
If you don't mind...this is my opinion...

I really think that the answer to all our questions is the love of God above everything else. If I look at the cross, I see PURE LOVE. A Loving sacrifies. If we look at the 10 commandments and the judicial law, I think this is meant only for one purpose...our perfection. Our Lord Jesus Christ has shown the way...obedient to the Father in a loving way. So now if I take kashrut for example...I see it as a loving sacrifies. A denial of oneself. I think, no man can really be condemned based on what he eats but rather what comes out of his mouth. I also think attempts to explain these dietary laws can really be explained better by simply looking at the cross.

Moreover, I also do not think there is a difference between between the old and the new. The old exposes what sin is and the punishment for it while our Lord Jesus Christ, victorious over sin, has shown us how to achieve perfect obedience...by loving God above all.

Re: "Like" One Under the Law

Posted: Thu Jun 18, 2009 11:26 pm
by mikemac
Ariel wrote:But where do the Scriptures ever make a distinction between the natural law/10 commandments and the judicial law? The fact is they don't.

Ariel
Actually they do Ariel. In the New Testament in Romans 13, Luke 18 and Matthew 19 Jesus repeats the ten commandments. I'm sure there are other spots in the New Testament as well. I've been meaning to post this for a while.

Mike